Join Bridge Winners
What’s needed for a 1S response

Hi agaIn.  In my recent poll (YBTJ) on an overbid game, I noticed a fairly wide discrepancy of opinions, with the top experts favoring accepting a 1D-1S-3S with JTxxx J9x xx Axx.  Fair enough.  From prior BW readings and polls I suspect that top experts are very likely to respond with 5 spades and almost anything, while average players might hold out for 4-5 hcp, implying that opener need have a more sound raise to 3S.  The following poll asks you to vote for the WEAKEST hand with which you’d respond to the 1D opener.   All hands have 5 spades and 5=3=2=3 shape.  I’m guessing that a 5 count with an ace would be enough for almost all.  If you think you’d be more/less inclined to pass with a third diamond (5=2=3=3 or 5=3=3=2) please comment separately. Thanks.

Noon EST edit:   Assume Std. Amer. 2/1 GF. 1D shows 4D unless specifically 4=4=3=2 (standard)

 

And after this I might ask about 4=3=3=3 hands.

Jxxxx xxx xx xxx
Jxxxx xxx xx Jxx
Jxxxx xxx xx Qxx
Jxxxx xxx xx Kxx
Jxxxx xxx xx Axx
Other

Sorry, to answer polls. Registered users can vote in polls, and can also browse other users' public votes! and participate in the discussion.

Getting results...
loading...
46 Comments
Getting Comments... loading...
.

Bottom Home Top