Join Bridge Winners
Rebidding a Diamond Suit

My partner and I play SAYC. Holding Q95, Q64, AQ42, Q73, he opened 1. I responded 2 holding K6, AJ98, K5, A9862. He rebid 2 showing a minimum. The rest of the auction is a bit hazy, but I eventually bid 3NT.

Holding A, K52, T973, KJT54, the opponent on opening lead, chose to lead the J (my first bid suit). Upon seeing her partner discard on trick 1, she screamed for the director. "He only has four diamonds! If I had known that his rebid didn't promise 5, I would have led a diamond!" (his first bid suit).

The director did not find damage as a result of the failure to alert, however, I received a lecture about alerting this bid in the future. I can't recall seeing my partner turn over four diamonds, and certainly not three diamonds on these auctions, but it is possible in our system. Alerting that my partner could have 3 diamonds on this auction seems (1) more misleading than helpful and (2) a waste of time.

If I am asked to alert this bid, should major suit rebids in 2/1 be alerted when they do/do not promise an additional card in the suit?

Thanks. Amy

 

Alert Diamond Rebid
Alert Not Necessary for Diamond Rebid
Other

Sorry, to answer polls. Registered users can vote in polls, and can also browse other users' public votes! and participate in the discussion.

Getting results...
loading...
47 Comments
Getting Comments... loading...
.

Bottom Home Top