Join Bridge Winners
Is G/B 2NT a Good or a Bad idea over 1-(2)-?

I arrived at our local Friday AM duplicate to find partner concerned about the auction 1-(2).  First, he asked what 3 showed.  I replied "competitive raise, not strongly invitational."

Then, he wanted to know about 2NT--shouldn't that be "Good/Bad."??  We play a lot of Good/Bad 2NT, and I am usually the advocate of using that treatment in many competitive auctions.

But here, I was dubious.  Since G/B 2NT here could, presumably, be "bad with s, s, or s, I thought this might cause our side a lot of problems when 4th hand raised to 3 (or 4).

I said that currently we had no special agreement about 2NT on this auction, so it was presumably natural and invitational.  But I also stated that I thought there would be merit in playing it as a strongish raise--probably a 4 card LR+ bid (ala Robson's "Partnership Bidding.").

But partner seemed adamant about G/B 2NT both because he liked the extra way to raise s below game, and because he liked the idea of having a way to show a minor single-suiter that was not strong enough to bid a (GF) 3m directly over (2).  He thought that the G/B 2NT toy would be perfect for solving both of these "problems."

So I reluctantly agreed to play 1-(2)-2NT as "Good/Bad", showing some sort of competitive but not GF hand, either with one long minor or with support.  With this treatment, an immediate 3 would be exactly invitational to game, while 3 cue-bid (and perhaps 4 too) would be available for game-going raises.

Anyway, I thought I'd take a BW poll to see what you all think about best treatment for 2NT on this auction.

So, after 1-(2)-, what do you recommend for a 2NT response?

2NT should be natural and invitational
2NT should be natural and forcing
2NT should be a 4 card invitational+ raise
2NT should be some other type of raise
2NT should be "Bad" part of "Good/Bad" with s, s, or s
2NT should be "Good" part of "Good/Bad" with s, s, or s
2NT should be "Bad" with a minor or "Good" with s
OTher. details appreciated

Sorry, to answer polls. Registered users can vote in polls, and can also browse other users' public votes! and participate in the discussion.

Getting results...
loading...
50 Comments
Getting Comments... loading...
.

Bottom Home Top