Join Bridge Winners
Director call - have I missed something?

North
Q1076
A543
42
J65
South
K954
107
QJ987
A2
W
N
E
S
P
1NT
P
P
X
P
2
P
2
P
2
P
2
P
P
P
 Matchpoints!

Me and my partner were a fairly new partnership with a few boards played in our career. Starting with the double we had exactly no idea what we were doing but after a few guesses we managed to reach our 4-4 in spades. 

Everything I will write now is exactly what happened at the table:

Lead was K. I took my normal 15s before playing from dummy. I won with my A and played another club in order to discard my heart. West won with Q and played a third club where I discarded my heart as planned. 

Now I attacked the diamonds and when my RHO played low I hesitated not more than 10s before playing Q. West won with K and played K which I won and continued a diamond where RHO played low again. Counting the points I knew West couldn´t have the ace as well so I played the Jack which held the trick. Now my RHO basicly stands up and says "I want to call the Director". So I finish the board scoring +170 after guessing the trumps for one loser. 

Director comes to the table and both my LHO and RHO says I was not allowed to think on the diamonds and that clearly mislead the defense (they were 3-3 so I have no clue what made him duck the ace in the first place). I clearly stated to them both I was hesitating for a few seconds if I should play the nine or the queen since I knew the honours were evenly split but came to a conclusion it will probably never benefit me to play the nine. They then said it is against the "Ethical Laws" to hesitate and then play the Queen from my hand. If I hesitate I have to play the Jack and not the Queen. The director who also carried around the EBL Laws in his pocket clearly agreed with the opponents that I am surely not allowed to play the queen after the hesitation. 

I have checked with a director who has a high status level in Sweden and he almost bursted out laughing listening to this Law because he never heard of it. 

I have myself heard and seen alot of absurd director calls in my bridge career. Letting a small hesitation decide which honour I am allowed to play sounds very strange to me. I just want to confirm, possibly with any WBF/ACBL director, if I´m wrong or if I missed something that´s new in the current WBF/EBL Laws?

77 Comments
Getting Comments... loading...
.

Bottom Home Top